Alexander’s is open Tuesday-Saturday

BAR 4:00 | DINNER 5:00


Dinner MenuCatering
Sesame Ahi Tuna
Tenderloin a la Oscar
tempura shrimp
previous arrow
next arrow


All of our entrees are served with our potato and vegetable du jour, a choice of house salad or cup of homemade soup, and fresh baked bread and butter.

Favorites include: Stuffed Pork Chop, Chicken Alexander, Shrimp Carbonara, New York Strip, BBQ Salmon, Roasted Cherry Duck, and more!



Our appetizers include Shrimp Tempura, Oysters Rockefeller, Ahi Tuna, Bruce’s Crostini Bread, Baked Artichoke Gorgonzola, and much more!

We also make all of our soups in-house, including Butternut Squash Bisque, Chicken Dumpling, and Cream of Chicken with Mushroom & Artichoke.



We make our desserts in-house, including our famous Chocolate Peanut Butter Torte, Bruce’s Baileys Chocolate Chip or White Chocolate Cherry cheesecake, Key Lime Pie, Flourless Chocolate Cake, and more. We also have our popular blended ice cream drinks!


What our customers are saying

“Cozy yet classy”

“Visited Alexander’s in Fish Creek, and I highly recommend the experience to anyone visiting Door County. The atmosphere was cozy yet classy. The appetizers were delicious. The drinks generous and well-made. The Friday night fish was done perfectly. Best walleye I’ve had in years! To top it all off, don’t miss the Brandy Alexander. I’ll be back.”



“Exceeded expectations for an open restaurant on a Tuesday evening. Delicious, attentive service, safe protocols. From the caesar salad, warm bread, generous portion of cherry salmon with potato and vegetable, we are already thinking about returning another night.”



“If you want a perfect meal in lovely surroundings with excellent wait staff who are unbelievably attentive, you need to eat here! The food was extraordinary. I had the lobster special, my husband had walleye. Not only were they melt in your mouth excellent, the sides were awesome. I’ve never tasted vegetables so delectable. The staff were so friendly and caring. Please go here sometime in your life!”


“Truly divine”

“Everything here was truly divine. From the ambience, to the way my steak my cooked/prepared. Truly blessed. Everything was on point and service was very attentive every single time we needed something.”